I often ask students what they like to do in their free time. As a college admissions consultant, I've noticed a concerning trend in the responses I receive. More often than not, these high-achieving students rattle off a list of school clubs, academic competitions, and resume-building activities. Rarely do I hear about hobbies or interests that truly reflect personal growth outside of academic success.

This laser focus on academic achievement, while admirable, may actually be hindering these students' college admissions prospects. Counterintuitively, some of the most academically successful students find themselves waitlisted at top institutions at alarmingly high rates. Why? Because they've neglected to develop a sense of self beyond their GPA and test scores.

The Overachiever's Dilemma

These students have mastered the art of academic success. They've aced every AP class, led multiple school clubs, and participated in numerous academic competitions. On paper, they look perfect. But herein lies the problem: they look too perfect, almost manufactured.

Admissions officers at top colleges aren't just looking for academic machines. They're seeking well-rounded individuals who will contribute to a diverse and vibrant campus community. They want to see passion, creativity, and a genuine interest in personal growth.

The Missing Piece: Personal Development

When I dig deeper and ask these students about their personal interests or what they do just for fun, I'm often met with blank stares or uncomfortable silences. Some might mention reading – but only books from the school curriculum. Others might talk about a hobby, but it's clear it's something they've only recently picked up to pad their application.

This lack of personal development outside of academics is a red flag for admissions officers. It suggests a one-dimensional personality and raises questions about how these students will adapt to the multifaceted challenges of college life.

The Importance of Authentic Interests

Colleges are looking for students who will bring unique perspectives and experiences to their campus. They want individuals who have:

1. Explored their passions beyond the classroom
2. Developed resilience through personal challenges
3. Engaged with their communities in meaningful ways
4. Cultivated interests that aren't tied to academic achievement

These qualities demonstrate maturity, self-awareness, and the ability to thrive in diverse environments – all crucial traits for success in college and beyond.

Breaking the Mold

If you're a high-achieving student (or the parent of one), it's crucial to step back and evaluate your approach to personal growth. Here are some suggestions:

• Pursue a hobby that has nothing to do with academics or resume-building
• Volunteer for a cause you're genuinely passionate about
• Take time for self-reflection and journaling
• Explore art, music, or other creative outlets
• Engage in physical activities or sports for the sheer enjoyment, not competition

Remember, colleges aren't looking for perfect students – they're looking for real people with unique stories, interests, and perspectives. So the next time you're tempted to join another academic club or sign up for an extra AP class, ask yourself: am I doing this because I truly want to, or am I just trying to pad my resume?

Take a moment to explore what really interests you outside of school. Develop hobbies that bring you joy, engage in activities that challenge you personally, and don't be afraid to show colleges the real you. After all, it's your unique personality and genuine interests that will make you stand out in the admissions process – not just another perfect GPA.